diff --git a/lib/error_tracker/error_notifier.ex b/lib/error_tracker/error_notifier.ex
index 8c64a920..9de2f4fa 100644
--- a/lib/error_tracker/error_notifier.ex
+++ b/lib/error_tracker/error_notifier.ex
@@ -30,7 +30,7 @@ defmodule ErrorTracker.ErrorNotifier do
         reason = truncate_reason(metadata.occurrence.reason)
 
         {_result, new_state} =
-          maybe_notify(metadata.occurrence, metadata.error.muted, "New Error! (#{reason})", state)
+          maybe_notify(metadata.occurrence, false, "New Error! (#{reason})", state)
 
         {:noreply, new_state}
 
@@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ defmodule ErrorTracker.ErrorNotifier do
         reason = truncate_reason(metadata.occurrence.reason)
 
         {_result, new_state} =
-          maybe_notify(metadata.occurrence, metadata.error.muted, "Error: #{reason}", state)
+          maybe_notify(metadata.occurrence, metadata.muted, "Error: #{reason}", state)
 
         {:noreply, new_state}
 
diff --git a/test/error_tracker/error_notifier_test.exs b/test/error_tracker/error_notifier_test.exs
index 0f6ebc2b..3709eade 100644
--- a/test/error_tracker/error_notifier_test.exs
+++ b/test/error_tracker/error_notifier_test.exs
@@ -124,8 +124,9 @@ defmodule ErrorTracker.ErrorNotifierTest do
 
       # Second notification for same error: throttled
       :telemetry.execute([:error_tracker, :occurrence, :new], %{}, %{
-        error: %ErrorTracker.Error{id: 1},
-        occurrence: occurrence(%{error_id: 1})
+        error: %Error{id: 1},
+        occurrence: occurrence(%{error_id: 1}),
+        muted: false
       })
 
       Process.sleep(50)
@@ -138,13 +139,24 @@ defmodule ErrorTracker.ErrorNotifierTest do
   describe "skipping" do
     test "skips notification when error is muted" do
       Application.put_env(:music_library, ErrorNotifier, @config)
+
       {:ok, pid} = ErrorNotifier.start_link([])
 
       :telemetry.execute([:error_tracker, :error, :new], %{}, %{
-        error: %Error{id: 1, muted: true},
+        error: %Error{id: 1},
         occurrence: occurrence(%{error_id: 1})
       })
 
+      Process.sleep(50)
+      assert_email_sent()
+
+      :telemetry.execute([:error_tracker, :occurrence, :new], %{}, %{
+        error: %Error{id: 2},
+        occurrence: occurrence(%{error_id: 2}),
+        muted: true
+      })
+
+      Process.sleep(50)
       refute_email_sent()
 
       GenServer.stop(pid)